Pennsylvania Judge Orders New Absentee Ballots for Voters Missing Mail-In Ballots

In a recent decision impacting Pennsylvania voters’ voting rights, District Judge David Ridge issued an order to provide absentee ballots and early voting options for voters who did not receive their mail-in ballots. This legal action affects approximately 17,000 Pennsylvania residents, ensuring they have alternative ways to cast their votes.

Voting Rights in Pennsylvania: The Problem of Missing Absentee Ballots

The ruling follows an investigation in Erie County where the county clerk, Karen Chilcott, noted delivery issues with the ballot vendor, Election IQ. Election IQ, in turn, pointed to potential delays from the United States Postal Service (USPS). Despite efforts from the Erie County Board of Elections, Election IQ, and USPS, the whereabouts of around 13,000 to 17,000 mail-in ballots remain unclear.

During the hearing, it was also revealed that 365 duplicate ballots were mistakenly sent to voters due to barcode errors. These issues have led to confusion and concerns over mail-in voting and absentee ballot security in Pennsylvania.

Pennsylvania Judge David Ridge’s Ruling

Judge Ridge’s order was crafted to address both the missing mail-in ballots and the duplicate ballot issues. His decision aims to protect the right to vote while ensuring that each vote counts only once. Here are the main provisions of the ruling:

  1. Extended Early Voting in Pennsylvania: The judge has extended early in-person voting by four days before Election Day. This allows affected voters to vote in person if they haven’t received their absentee ballots.
  2. New Absentee Ballots for Out-of-State Voters: Out-of-state voters who applied for but did not receive their absentee ballots will be sent new ballots to ensure they can vote.
  3. Canceling Duplicate Ballots: Voters who received duplicate ballots can submit a new ballot to cancel any previously cast ballot, preventing any unintentional duplicate voting.

Pennsylvania Democratic Party Lawsuit Over Voting Access

This ruling follows a lawsuit by the Pennsylvania Democratic Party, which sought emergency relief for voters who did not receive their mail-in ballots. The case demonstrates the importance of voter access and election security as key issues in Pennsylvania.

Voting Rights and Recent U.S. Supreme Court Decision

Judge Ridge’s ruling aligns with a recent U.S. Supreme Court decision, which upheld a Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruling allowing voters to correct defective ballots by casting provisional ballots in person. These cases highlight ongoing efforts to uphold voter rights in Pennsylvania amid challenges with mail-in and absentee voting processes.

What Pennsylvania Voters Need to Know About Absentee and Mail-In Voting

This ruling is a win for voter rights in Pennsylvania, especially for those facing issues with absentee or mail-in ballots. Pennsylvania residents affected by missing ballots or duplicate ballots now have clear options to ensure their votes are counted. If you or someone you know has been impacted by mail-in ballot issues, follow these guidelines to secure your right to vote.


Elias Legal Firm is committed to providing updates on legal issues affecting voter rights in Pennsylvania. If you have questions about your voting rights, absentee ballots, or other legal matters, contact us for guidance. We’re here to help you understand your rights and ensure your voice is heard in the voting process.

Contact us today for a free consultation

Greensburg Office

206 N. Main St.

Greensburg, PA 15601

Uniontown Office

45 E. Main St.

Suite 400 Uniontown Pa, 15401

724-562-5140

*Cities also include: Uniontown, Connellsville, Brownsville, Masontown, Mt. Pleasant, Scottsdale, Latrobe, Murrysville, Irwin, Ligonier, Hempfield, Desmond, New Stanton.
Scroll to Top